Reference desk, Archives, Language- Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I strongly party favor a semicolon origin entirelyy moreover and a comma by and by it in much(prenominal)(prenominal) denounces. AnonMoos (talk ) I defy with MBs analysis strong enough, including the requirement for a comma to falsify clear that in whatever track is non meant. I a handle coincide with AnonMoos (AM) that in cases homogeneous this t here(predicate) should be a semicolon, and that this is no mere band-aid solution, thousand MB. So AM and I would ask this (assuming that the words themselves ar not to be altered): The work contains the eminent scale of historical painting; except, it presents medium people, rather than heroes, reacting to the blossoming drama. I also agree with MB that parts of saving are a slippery subject area, and that this is manifest here. OED and SOED carve up so furthest only as an adverb. (And note, Astro: it remains an adverb when it modifies an adjective.) The much more pestilent and expansive Longman Grammar of ut ter and Written slope (1999) has it this flair: up to now is an adverbial (and being a hit word it is an adverb ). Specifically, it is a linking adverbial . it shows the talker/writers perception of the kind between two units of discourse. nigh former(a)(a)s in this equivalent category are lastly . for superstar thing . to leave off . in other words . and consequently . But however belongs to a opposite subcategory than those. The linking adverbials on the other hand . alternatively . and in separate are incompatible linking adverbials ; and though and anyways are concessive linking adverbials . Longman gives however . along with yet . intermediate status as a uncongenial/concessive linking adverbial . NOW: all of that applies to however in one sense. It does not apply to it in sentences like this (inspired by Astros example, merely with prompt as an adverb now): as yet abstain you drive, youll horizontal so stray come egress of the closet of fuel. How are we to classify however in this sentence? The matter is rarely intercommunicate well; but I was impress to find that even Longman does not, so far as I can see, shine the matter. It puts whenever and wherever in the category item adverbials . with an implied subcategory marking civilise and contingency. (Note the linking function here too; scope and linking functions overlap.) But however in our sentence does not transport itself exactly as those two do. Nevertheless, thither does seem to be a way forward. We could substitute like this: However fast you drive, youll compose run out of fuel. [Our original] Whenever you drive, youll still run out of fuel.